← Back to Televersant
COMPARISON GUIDE

Choosing RF Planning Software: Complete Comparison Guide

An in-depth comparison of leading RF planning tools including Atoll, iBWave, Planet, and ASSET. Learn which platform best fits your wireless network design needs, budget, and technical requirements.

Updated: January 2026 14 min read

Quick Comparison Overview

Tool Best For Price Range Learning Curve Overall Rating
Atoll Macro networks, 5G planning $15K-$40K/license Medium
★★★★★ (9.2/10)
iBWave Design In-building, DAS, small cells $8K-$25K/license Low-Medium
★★★★★ (9.0/10)
Planet (Infovista) Multi-vendor optimization $20K-$50K/license High
★★★★☆ (8.7/10)
ASSET (Aircom) Interference analysis, spectrum $12K-$35K/license Medium-High
★★★★☆ (8.5/10)

Atoll (Forsk)

Industry-leading macro network planning tool

9.2/10
Overall Score

Strengths

  • Comprehensive 5G NR Support: Best-in-class 5G planning with mmWave, beamforming, and Massive MIMO modeling
  • Excellent Documentation: Extensive user manual, video tutorials, and active user community
  • Fast Performance: Efficient processing engine handles large networks (10,000+ sites) smoothly
  • Flexible Licensing: Modular add-ons allow purchasing only needed features
  • API & Automation: Python API enables scripting and batch processing

Weaknesses

  • Windows Only: No Mac or Linux support limits flexibility
  • In-Building Limitations: Not ideal for detailed indoor planning (use iBWave instead)
  • Steep Initial Investment: High upfront cost for full feature set
  • Annual Maintenance: Requires 20% annual fee for updates and support

Best Use Cases:

  • • Macro cellular network design (2G/3G/4G/5G)
  • • 5G NR deployment planning
  • • Large-scale carrier networks
  • • Greenfield network design
  • • Multi-technology optimization
  • • Spectrum refarming studies

Televersant's Recommendation:

Best choice for carriers and consultants focused on macro network planning. Atoll is our primary tool for 5G deployments and large-scale RF optimization projects. The investment pays off quickly for teams planning more than 100 sites per year. Start with the Standard edition and add modules as needed.

iBWave Design

The industry standard for in-building wireless design

9.0/10
Overall Score

Strengths

  • In-Building Excellence: Unmatched for DAS, small cell, and indoor coverage design
  • CAD Integration: Import floor plans from AutoCAD, Revit, and other formats
  • Material Database: Extensive library of building materials with measured RF properties
  • Professional Reports: Automated BOM, coverage reports, and installation drawings
  • User-Friendly: Intuitive interface with gentle learning curve

Weaknesses

  • Not for Outdoor: Limited macro network planning capabilities
  • Processing Speed: Large buildings (100k+ sq ft) can be slow to calculate
  • Limited Automation: Batch processing requires enterprise edition
  • Subscription Model: Moving to mandatory annual subscriptions

Best Use Cases:

  • • DAS system design
  • • In-building coverage solutions
  • • Enterprise wireless design
  • • Stadium and venue systems
  • • Hospital and healthcare facilities
  • • Public safety ERRCS compliance

Televersant's Recommendation:

Essential tool for any firm doing in-building work. iBWave is the de facto standard for DAS and indoor coverage design. The professional reports and automated bill of materials alone justify the investment. We use iBWave daily for hospital, stadium, and enterprise building projects. Start with iBWave Design Enterprise for full capabilities.

Planet (Infovista)

Comprehensive network planning and optimization suite

8.7/10
Overall Score

Strengths

  • Multi-Vendor Support: Excellent integration with Ericsson, Nokia, Huawei, Samsung equipment
  • Optimization Focus: Strong post-deployment optimization and troubleshooting capabilities
  • Network Analytics: Advanced KPI monitoring and performance analysis
  • ACP Integration: Automatic Cell Planning for parameter optimization

Weaknesses

  • Complex Interface: Steeper learning curve than Atoll or iBWave
  • High Cost: Premium pricing, especially for full optimization suite
  • Vendor Lock-In: Best value comes with multi-year enterprise agreements
  • Resource Intensive: Requires powerful workstations for large networks

Best Use Cases:

  • • Multi-vendor network optimization
  • • Post-deployment tuning
  • • Large carrier networks
  • • Performance troubleshooting
  • • Automated parameter optimization
  • • Network modernization projects

Televersant's Recommendation:

Best for carriers with existing multi-vendor networks needing optimization. Planet excels at ongoing network performance management rather than greenfield design. The ROI comes from improved network KPIs and reduced optimization cycles. Consider if you're managing 500+ sites across multiple vendors. For planning-only needs, Atoll offers better value.

ASSET (Aircom)

Advanced spectrum planning and interference analysis

8.5/10
Overall Score

Strengths

  • Interference Modeling: Industry-leading interference analysis and visualization
  • Spectrum Management: Excellent tools for frequency planning and allocation
  • Regulatory Compliance: Built-in coordination studies for regulatory filings
  • Microwave Planning: Strong backhaul link planning capabilities

Weaknesses

  • Limited 5G Features: Behind competitors in 5G NR modeling
  • Dated Interface: UI feels older compared to Atoll or iBWave
  • Niche Focus: Specialized tool, not a complete planning solution
  • Training Required: Advanced features require specialized training

Best Use Cases:

  • • Spectrum coordination studies
  • • Interference troubleshooting
  • • Regulatory filings (FCC, etc.)
  • • Microwave backhaul design
  • • Frequency refarming projects
  • • Cross-border coordination

Televersant's Recommendation:

Specialized tool for spectrum and interference work. ASSET complements Atoll rather than replacing it. We use ASSET for complex interference scenarios and regulatory coordination studies, but rely on Atoll for primary planning. Consider ASSET if you frequently deal with spectrum licensing, cross-border coordination, or dense urban interference issues.

How to Choose the Right Tool

Step 1: Define Your Primary Use Case

If you primarily design macro cellular networks: Choose Atoll

If you focus on in-building/DAS projects: Choose iBWave Design

If you optimize existing multi-vendor networks: Consider Planet

If you handle spectrum coordination: Add ASSET as supplement

Step 2: Consider Your Budget

  • Limited Budget ($5K-$15K): Start with iBWave Design Standard or Atoll Basic
  • Mid-Range ($15K-$30K): Atoll Standard + iBWave Enterprise is solid combination
  • Enterprise ($50K+): Full Atoll suite + iBWave + specialized tools as needed

Step 3: Evaluate Your Team's Experience

New to RF planning: Start with iBWave (easiest learning curve)

Experienced RF engineers: Atoll or Planet offer more advanced features

Large team: Invest in comprehensive training for chosen platform

Step 4: Plan for Integration

Most firms benefit from owning multiple tools:

  • Atoll for macro planning + iBWave for indoor work (most common)
  • Planet for optimization + Atoll for greenfield design
  • ASSET as supplement for any primary tool when doing spectrum work

Recommended Toolset by Firm Type

Small Consultant (1-5 engineers)

Core: iBWave Design Enterprise ($12K)
Add when needed: Atoll Standard ($18K)
Total Investment: $12K-$30K

Start with iBWave for in-building work. Add Atoll when you win macro network projects.

Mid-Size Firm (5-20 engineers)

Core: Atoll Standard (3 licenses, $54K)
Add: iBWave Enterprise (2 licenses, $24K)
Optional: ASSET Standard ($15K)
Total Investment: $78K-$93K

Cover both macro and in-building capabilities. Share licenses across team.

Regional Carrier (20-100 engineers)

Core: Atoll Enterprise (10 licenses, $300K)
Add: Planet Standard (5 licenses, $120K)
Add: iBWave (5 licenses, $60K)
Add: ASSET (2 licenses, $30K)
Total Investment: $510K

Full toolset for planning, optimization, and troubleshooting.

National Carrier (100+ engineers)

Core: Enterprise agreements with all vendors
Atoll: Unlimited licenses ($500K-$1M)
Planet: Full optimization suite ($400K-$800K)
iBWave + ASSET: Team licenses ($200K+)
Total Investment: $1.1M-$2M+

Negotiate enterprise agreements. Include training and dedicated support.

Need Help Selecting RF Planning Tools?

Televersant has extensive experience with all major RF planning platforms. We can help you evaluate your needs, negotiate pricing, and provide training to get your team productive quickly.

Schedule a Consultation

© 2026 Televersant. All rights reserved.

Return to Televersant Home